Integrated In-Class Presentation: Advantages, Disadvantages and Considerations
Advantages
- Easiest form of instruction to set up.
- Promotes collaboration with lecture and laboratory instructors.
- Students are usually motivated, since the lecture materials will
tie directly into some course assignment.
- When linked to a well-designed assignment, the topics to be covered
are usually easy to figure out.
- Students are usually all at about the same level of knowledge, so
you aren't boring half the class while the other half doesn't
understand what you're talking about.
- Since these students will be in the library anyway, one hour in the
classroom can save you many hours at the reference desk.
Disadvantages
- Instructor collaboration isn't always forthcoming.
- Sometimes trying to fit everything you want to cover into a single
lecture can be daunting.
- If you're going to meet in the usual classroom, live demos of
electronic sources may not be possible.
Considerations
- Try to reach out to instructors early (over the summer for fall
courses), so that your lecture can be fit into the schedule
appropriately — either at the best time to match the assignment,
or to take advantage of a session when the instructor would be
unable to lecture anyway.
- Link the lecture to one or more assignments that are a significant
part of the course to add relevance.
- If electronic resources are to be covered, try to arrange for live
demos. If not, consider “canned” presentations using
presentation software, or Web browsers.
- Whatever your presentation is, distill its essence into a handout —
some students take poor notes; others may miss your lecture, and it
may come in handy for patrons not in the class. If you have the
chance, create a Web version.
- Hands-on training in a one-hour lecture probably isn't doable. If
you have more time, it may be worthwhile.
Author: Chuck Huber (huber@library.ucsb.edu)