Comments
about the Course - 2022 & 2023
Contents
2023
2022
Other
Contents
2022 - Anonymous comments from
the last class session's Course Evaluation Form by students and community
members:
-
Thank you so much, Dave!
This is one of the courses that make Stanford the special place that it
is.
-
Loved working with Mary to
develop a functional prototype.
-
[I had a] great
relationaship with our project partner and our project was a huge
success.
-
[Our course and project
experience] was great. Our team got really close, and we loved working with our
community partner. We learned a lot.
-
Stanford PRL is the best
place to build a product as an engineer.
-
This was a wonderful
class. I only wish I had taken it for 3 units.
-
[I liked the] broad areas
of topics, opportunities to interact with people working in the
field.
-
Everything went well and
I'm happy with our [team's] final prototype.
-
Awesome class, would
recommend.
-
I liked the course
structure and guest lecturers.
-
Grat class. Thank you for
the opportunity to learn!
-
[The field trip to the
Magical Bridge Playgound was] amazing! [It was my] favorite class session of
the year (out of all my Fall & Winter classes).
-
I loved getting to know
the community members and fellow students. I was able to balance my time while
committing to making a successful product. Amazing course,
thanks!
-
I had a great relationship
with out community partners - they are amazing people. They helped work us
through the problem and commented on all three of our prototypes. Awesome
class, super grateful.
-
I thought this course was
very well taught and provides design (and practice) insights that more people
in this world could use to be more inclusive and make the world more more
accessible.
-
I think I did way more
work than expected of a one-unt course, but it was all helpful
work.
-
[I] formed incredible
bonds with our community partner & family. Everyone was very invested in
helpig one another and the open flow of communication was essential to making a
meaningful design. Great people & amazing experience. :-) The porject
experience was incredibly rewarding and engaging. I'm so glad I took the class
and grateful for everyone who made it happen.
-
[From Idea to Market] was
my favorite [lecture].
-
[I] really liked the
message of designing for the user [in the lecture: Issues of Human Interface
Design].
-
Best class @
Stanford!
-
Highly recommended to all
others.
-
I found this course most
useful in the opportunity to connect with and learn from people who live with
physical disabilities.
-
Great project. [I]
appreciated relationship with community members. [The] weekly meetings were
very helpful.
-
[Perspectives of Stanford
Students and Faculty with a Disability was the] best lecture by far - why this
is important in the first place.
-
[The course] was a really
nice experience overall. I liked seeing the impact of the
project.
|
Contents
2023 - Emailed comments from
students when they submitted their End-of-term Reports or Individual
Reflections:
-
Thanks for a great
class!
-
It has been a pleasure to
be in your course! Thank you so much for EVERYTHING! I'm wearing my t-shirt
right now! The burritos! The lessons! Your time and commitment to the class!
Thank you so much!
-
Thank you for teaching a
wonderful course this quarter. I really enjoyed it and feel like I got a lot
out of it.
-
Thank you again for a
great quarter of learning and designing!
-
I really enjoyed this
course.
-
Thank you for such an
exciting and valuable course. I am excited to spread the word about this
class.
-
I really truly enjoyed
this class! It was super super cool! Working with Danny was also very very
rewarding.
-
Thank you so so much for
everything you did for us this quarter from providing us with cookies
every lecture, to an incredible line up of speakers and the very cool fair, to
your kindness and wisdom. It was fantastic learning from you this
quarter.
-
Thank you so much for
teaching such a fun and informative class. I had such a meaningful experience
learning from you and the guest lecturers and creating a direct impact on
Danny's life! Have a great spring break!
-
Thank you for a great
quarter.
-
Thanks again for hosting
an incredible class for all of us.
-
Attached is a link to my
individual reflection. I realized that while writing my reflection I may have
written far over the expected word count. I honestly had such a good experience
with this class and want the Haas Center For Public Service to continue funding
this class. It is about 4 pages double spaced at the moment and I included
pictures at the end. However, please let me know if you would prefer a
condensed version. I can send that over if that is
preferred.
-
Again, I wanted to say
thank you so much for this course. This was seriously the best course I have
ever taken at Stanford. I am really so grateful to have had the opportunity
to learn from you, Ayano, my peers, project suggesters and all of the wonderful
guest lecturers that were involved this quarter.
-
Thank you so much for a
great quarter!
-
Thank you for offering
such an amazing class!
-
Thank you for an amazing
quarter of learning and growth.
-
Thank you so much for an
incredible class. We have all learned so much about working as a team,
designing for individuals with disabilities, and many perspectives in assistive
technology. This was a truly rewarding experience.
-
We have had an amazing
quarter of learning from you, our guest speakers, and community members. This
project was a wonderful experience and we truly appreciate the guidance,
effort, and thought put in by the teaching team.
-
Thank you so much for an
incredible quarter.
-
Thank you so much for all
of your effort in putting together a wonderful learning experience this
quarter!
-
Thank you for an amazing
quarter! I learned so much and had a very fun time too.
-
I really enjoyed being in
the class.
-
Thank you so much for the
great class and all the cookies! :-)
-
Thank you for an amazing
quarter. Your class will stick with me for many years to
come.
-
Thank you for offering the
great class and the guidance.
-
Thanks for a great
quarter!
-
I'd like to thank you
again for your time and effort in this class, I've learned a lot and enjoyed
creating something that could help Cat so much.
-
Thank you again for a
great quarter of learning!
-
I would like to thank you
for being so accommodating to me this quarter with my travel and giving me the
opportunity to take this course. I will highly recommend this course to my
teammates so hopefully you will get a couple more that can help change the
world.
-
Thank you for such an
incredible quarter, it was truly a pleasure to take this class and learn from
such a great group of people!
-
Thanks for a great
quarter! I very much enjoyed the class and guest speakers.
-
Thanks again for teaching
this class, I think it was a really rewarding experience!
-
Thank you again for an
insightful quarter of learning! I am grateful for all the lessons I learned
from this course and will use them in a variety of ways!
-
I want to thank you for an
amazing course and for all your grace in waiting for my
reflection.
|
Contents
2022 - Emailed comments from
students when they submitted their End-of-term Reports:
-
Thank you again for
leading such an impactful course.
-
Thank you both for all
your support and feedback throughout the quarter I hope you have a
restful break and a great spring quarter!
-
I really am so thankful
for all your time and effort this quarter. ENGR 110 has been one of my favorite
classes at Stanford. I hope to stay in touch throughout my years
here.
-
Thank you so much for a
great quarter and I hope to stay in touch in the future.
-
Thank you again so much
for teaching this course this year; I learned so much from both of you, our
guest speakers, and most of all through my individual
project.
-
Thanks again for a great
quarter!
-
Thank you for an amazing
class and the opportunity to meet so many cool people! Thank you for an amazing
quarter!
-
Thanks so much for all
your time this quarter, it has been a real highlight for me to be able to
discuss each week's presentations together. I really appreciate all the energy
that went into this course, and especially your willingness to offer this
asynchronous option.
-
Thank you and Kat so much
for a great quarter, I really enjoyed the class.
-
This course has been one
of the best courses I have taken in any academic setting. Having returned from
a long leave your course made me realize what I missed most about being at
Stanford.
-
I really enjoyed this
class this quarter. I particularly enjoyed our weekly lecture summary meetings.
I thought those conversations we had were some of the biggest things Ill
take away from this course. I really enjoyed it. I hope you have a great rest
of the week and I hope to meet you in person when it is safe to do
so!
-
Thank you for an awesome
quarter. Wishing you both the best.
-
Thanks again for a great
quarter and for your flexibility allowing a medical student in the
class.
-
I wanted to give you both
a huge thank you for a wonderful quarter! I really appreciate all your work in
successfully converting the class to a remote format while keeping it lively
and engaging. I have learned a great deal from you and all the guest lecturers,
and had a fantastic time working on the project. This has definitely been one
of the most fulfilling classes I've taken at Stanford.
-
Have a great rest of your
week - thank you again for a wonderful quarter!
-
Thank you for teaching
this class this quarter!
-
Thanks for the past 10
weeks :)
-
Thanks again for a
fantastic quarter!
-
Thank you very much for a
great quarter, I learned a ton and loved being apart of a great
class.
|
Contents
Emailed comments from
community members:
-
I really enjoyed the
Assistive Technology Faire last night. Networking with other professionals and
sharing with students was great! I sent my email contact to your student who is
designing the one handed cutting station. It sounds great! I have only use of 1
hand myself due to a stroke so that item really resonated with
me.
-
Thank you again for the
invitation to attend your class. This was a great class, and I am very thankful
I had the opportunity to observe. I enjoyed all the classes. The student
presentations were very impressive, and I enjoyed them too.
-
I thought all your
students did an excellent job. They obviously spent a great deal of time on
these projects and had some very good ideas.
-
I just joined the last two
sessions, however, so impressed by their high-quality presentations. I can
imagine how you well-organized this course even in the COVID-19 pandemic
situation. Thank you so much for inviting me to this course. I learned a lot.
Please keep in touch.
|
Contents
Miscellaneous comments from
students:
-
I had an excellent time
learning in your class last quarter and look forward to working on another
project under your guidance.
|
Contents
2022 - Comments from Cardinal
Course Student Survey:
-
I found it valuable to
engage in a real project where I created a more accessible experience. It
helped me to gain perspective as a designer and truly understand and apply the
principles we were learning.
-
I really enjoy being able
to work with a real community partner and build something that they will be
able to use long after the conclusion of the class.
-
It felt like my work was
more than just a project/report for a class. Rather, I was making something
impactful that had a tangible difference in the world.
|
Contents
2023 - Comments from Cardinal
Course Student Survey:
-
My community partner
provided great insights and feedback as we created and designed the assistive
device, which really opened my eyes to the power of involving users in the
design process.
-
A course concept that I
encountered in my project was the ability to respectfully engage and meet the
needs of people with disabilities. I was able to practice this concept in real
life.
-
Gaining more understanding
of the perspectives of other people with disabilities [was what I found
valuable about the community engaged project experience].
-
I found the user testing
with our community partner to be incredibly valuable and such a unique
opportunity.
-
Hearing from a panel of
students with disabilities about their experience at Stanford was incredibly
powerful.
-
There was a lot of respect
for people with disabilities.
-
We talked about interview
skills when talking with community partners to show
respect.
|
Contents
Comments from 2022 Registrar
Student Course Evaluations: - Some comments related to
networking and Zoom issues have been removed.
|
2022 Registrar
-
Student replies to "What
skills or knowledge did you learn or improve?"
-
I loved that the
course surveyed a variety of fields relevant to assistive technology, including
design, technology development, commercialization, and academia. The course
lectures are high-level and are easy enough to comprehend by students from
different backgrounds and majors. The project was an incredibly enriching
experience for me - it was my first time at the PRL, and I learned so much
about the design process and the importance of prototyping for learning
forward.
-
My understanding of
disability and assistive technologies.
-
How to approach a
design project and knowledge of the broad field of assistive technology as well
as ethical considerations related to designing in this
space.
-
I am much better at
prototyping.
-
I learned about
challenges surrounding the design of assistive technology and different
existing solutions for improving the lives of individuals with
disabilities.
-
Empathy, thinking
outside the box.
-
Learned how to apply
the mechanical design process for assistive technology.
-
How to make more
accessible products.
-
How to interact with
the disability community, prototype.
-
Had exposure to 3D
printing, rapid prototyping, magnets, laser jet, sheet metal cutting, sowing,
and much more.
-
Learned about
accessibility and how to create a prototype.
-
I learned a lot about
the intersection of engineering and assistive technology.
-
I learned about some
new assistive technologies.
-
Film
-
I learned a lot about
the field of assistive technologies and the range of work and people being
accounted for.
|
2022 Registrar
-
Student replies to "What
would you like to say about this course to a student who is considering taking
it in the future?"
-
Definitely take it!
The course lectures cover a variety of fields under the theme of accessibility:
design, academia, product development, commercialization, etc. The lectures are
high-level and are not technically complex, they're comprised of guest
lecturers giving overviews of their fields. The project component was super
fun, and I learned a lot because I got to work at the PRL for the first time.
You'll be the one to define the scope of your project which ends up defining
how much time you spend on the course. Overall, definitely recommended - one of
the most fun courses I've taken at Stanford.
-
Its a
warm course driven by a very humane cause. The projects are likely
the most user-centered projects youll ever deal with, many being
one-of-one projects solving a very particular need. While this may not be
fulfilling the needs of thousands, that one individual that youve helped
will benefit greatly and that aspect of the course is extremely
rewarding.
-
Great class with very
cool project options. You get out of it what you put in.
-
The opportunity to
create a device that will improve the quality of life for a community member is
amazing.
-
This is a great course
to learn about assistive technology considerations and design. Very interactive
and personal class where you get to work on a project of your choosing to help
a real person.
-
Guest lectures are
cool, personal project is cool! find something you're passionate
about.
-
Great course,
incredible teaching team, good times.
-
Recommend taking the
course as part of a team project. Eye-opening experience.
-
Great class and it's
not too overwhelming! Super fun especially if you get to go to the Magical
Bridge Playground to see how they've been able to make playgrounds
accessible.
-
A really great class!
great perspective to be introduced to the disability community. Choose an
interesting topic to you and also have good teammates, ideally take it with
some people you know! Defenitely don't miss the Magical Bridge Playground
fieldtrip, and work early on your prototypes. Meet often with your community
partner. Dave is nice and open to meet often - take advantage especially of the
CA too! A manageable project class but depends how much effort you put
in.
-
The course might feel
like more than a three-unit class if you choose to take it for that course
load, so be prepared to do a lot of independent work!
-
Dave is the best! This
course is an absolute must take at Stanford. In the course, you have the option
to work on a group project to solve a real life challenge for someone who has a
mobility or vision impairment. The community members are great. Dave serves
fresh chocolate chip cookies every class. The last day of class, he brings
burritos from Treehouse. His guest lecturers are fantastic. I have had so much
fun taking his course, I will be pursuing independent study with him in the
spring. Remember, ENGR 110/210 is only taught in the winter, so make sure to
put it in your schedule. Several students this quarter, repeated the class for
either independent study or as grad students. Have made so many great friends
from this class. Loved the class. One of my highlights at
college.
-
Take it! Took it for 3
units and enjoyed my quarter long project. Make sure you have a good group and
pick a project you are passionate about though. You get out what you put in and
it was cool to expand my perspective on assistive
technology.
-
Make sure you attend
the class. Easy if you're taking it for 1 unit.
-
Working on the project
was great.
-
If you are interested
in all types of assistive technologies it is a good class.
-
Loved loved the class
and the project was SUPER enjoyable.
-
The course is
fantastic. It is one of those classes that provide a tremendous amount of
meaning and context to how engineering can create a real-world impact. I think
the lectures can be a hit or a miss, so filling out Daves evaluation form
after each guest lecture is really important to improve the next iteration of
the course. If you take the class for 3 units and work with a team, you learn
and practice a tremendous amount of skills. You have total ownership over the
project and define the timeline (other than when midterm presentations and
final presentations roll around). You learn how to listen and work with your
project partner to create a solution that fits their needs, and you learn how
to scope a project to be manufacturable within the 10 weeks youre taking
the course.
-
Team and project
choice are important.
-
Fun
-
The guest speakers are
pretty interesting.
|
2022 Registrar
-
Student replies to "Would
you like to provide any other comments about this course?"
-
I had a great time
learning and I'm extremely grateful this class is offered at Stanford. Also, if
this class could be a part of Meet the Makers. I think that would be really
cool! I think other PRL students would benefit from the
exposure.
|
Contents
Feedback from 2023 Course
Evaluations:
|
2023 Course Feedback
-
Student replies to "What
skills or knowledge did you learn or improve?"
-
I learned how to
approach and speak about people with disabilities. I was able to learn about
their perspectives as people with disabilities.
-
Produce
fabrication
-
I learned how to use
PRL, develop a prototype, how to design products WITH people with disabilites
to create effective assistive technologies.
-
I learned about
assistive technologies and improved my design skills.
-
Exposed to many
disabilities and became more equipped on how to have a useful impact with
assistive technologies.
-
How to design products
for a person who has some form of disability.
-
People
skills.
-
Prototyping
skills.
-
I learned how to work
together with your user to co-design an effective assistive
technology.
-
I learned about
assistive technology and how its key principles can be applied to several other
industries.
|
2023 Course Feedback
-
Student replies to "What
would you like to say about this course to a student who is considering taking
it in the future?"
-
Take this class! The
speakers are amazing & the project you would on are really meaningful to
the person with the disability. I recommend. It's interesting &
low-stress.
-
Dave really cares
about the students. He is so kind and I learned so much from this course. If
you are an STS major you will get pushed to pick up some engineering skills in
a very short time period so be wary of that. This class is AWESOME overall. I
think it should be advertised more on campus because it is truly
special!!
-
Dave put a lot of work
into the guest lectures and they were very informative. ME background is a
plus, but not necessary. Good overview of assistive technology, I would
recommend taking the course.
-
A lot of cool guest
speakers. You make a prototype on something to improve the quality of life and
independence for a community member with disabilities if taken for 3 units. I
would recommend coming in with some product fabrication experiences (or find
teammates with fabrication experiences) because they don't teach that in class
and nobody in my team have used PRL before. I think the outcome would be better
if at least one person knew how to do stuff.
-
You get to interact
with some pretty amazing people.
-
There is no time in
class for project work so make sure you get started early!!
-
A good experience and
a nice introduction to whats being done in the field of assistive
technology.
-
It's such a valuable
class, take it if you can!
-
Awesome
class.
-
Amazing and rewarding
class if you take on a project. It's a great chance to work together with a
user and design a product that will directly impact their
life.
-
Be sure to start the
Team Project ahead of time (even if the first few meetings are just
brainstorming.
|
2023 Course Feedback
-
Student replies to "Would
you like to provide any other comments about this course?"
-
This is a wonderful
class!
-
Super awesome way to
get engaged with community and make a direct impact!
|
|