Tuesday, October 28, 5:15pm
SocioRap: Ethnicity and Phonetic Variation in a San Francisco Neighborhood
Stanford University
Dissertation Proposal Talk
This talk examines the emergence of ethnic indices in the
context of
regional vowel shifts. My analysis draws on the local
meanings of
phonetic variables, showing that those meanings blur
boundaries
between traditional notions of ethnicity and region.
Data come from a subset of sociolinguistic interviews
conducted in
Spring 2008 with 86 English-dominant speakers from the
Sunset
District, a working/middle class neighborhood of San
Francisco,
California. The neighborhood has undergone rapid
demographic change
over the past few decades. What was once a predominantly
Irish
Catholic neighborhood is now approximately 43% White and
51% Asian,
with 77% of those Asian Americans identifying as Chinese.
In a city
full of trendy neighborhoods, this "sleepy" residential
district is
seen by its residents as authentically San Francisco. For
some
people, the Sunset's dominant Asian population adds to
this sense of
local authenticity. Most residents, regardless of
ethnicity, have
multiple social ties to Asian Americans, and Asian
identities are
considered "cool" for some younger people. Through
these links to San
Francisco authenticity, I suggest that indexical resources
of
Asianness become available to the wider neighborhood
community. At
the same time, sound changes not indexing ethnicity are
progressing
across the population as a whole.
This talk focuses on three linguistic variables: the split
movement of
the (ow) vowel, the vocalization of coda-/l/, and the
merger of the
low back vowel classes. The fronting of (uw) and (ow) are
well-
recognized components of the Northern California vowel
shift (NCVS),
occurring in all phonological environments except preceding
/l/
(Hinton et al. 1987; Luthin 1987). As a relatively recent
innovation
in California, fronting is more frequent among younger
speakers in the
Sunset District, both White and Asian American. At the
same time,
other young speakers, particularly Asian Americans, produce
extremely
backed variants of these vowels. Given the prevalence of
back vowel
fronting across California and across ethnicities,
production of
backed variants within the context of the NCVS appears to
index an
orientation to the Sunset District neighborhood and local
meanings of
ethnicity, rather than marking ethnicity as a context-free
category
(Eckert, to appear).
Secondly, some second-generation Asian Americans produce
fully
vocalized coda- or coda-cluster-/l/ (e.g., COLD
approximates CODE).
That Whites and higher-generation Asian Americans show more
constrained /l/-vocalization suggests that this variable is
a
nativization of a second language feature, and a potential
linguistic
resource for Sunset District speakers that is more clearly
indexical
of ethnicity than is the movement of (ow). Finally,
despite evidence
for the regional prominence of the low back merger (Labov
et al. 2006)
and its early presence in San Francisco in particular
(DeCamp 1953),
my data supports the finding that the COT and CAUGHT
classes are still
distinct for some San Franciscans (Moonwomon 1987, 1992;
Labov et al.
2006). Furthermore, the distinction is found for both
Whites and
Asian Americans, correlating significantly with age group
rather than
ethnicity.